Copart
Revenue 2016: $1.3bn2025: $4.6bn
Counted on the 13 of 15 questions that could be answered from the filings. A second reader, working blind from the same quotes, arrived at 86.0 with 10 answered.
A study note on how the company fits a fixed list of questions. Not a view on the shares, not a recommendation. How the marks are made
Position heldThe author holds shares in this company. Stated on 21 November 2026.
01Quiet leadership
100 of 100 2 of 3 answeredThe chief executive credits others and owns the misses
Could not assess
The last two letters to shareholders and what the chief executive says alongside results.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe filings read hold no letter from the chief executive and no earnings call. Whether he credits others and owns misses cannot be checked.
No checked quote is on file for this question. The company's filings at sec.gov
The chief executive grew up inside the company
5 of 5
The biography in the proxy statement.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe proxy statement says 'Willis J. Johnson and A. Jayson Adair are company founders'. Adair is chief executive from July 31, 2026.
Willis J. Johnson and A. Jayson Adair are company founders.
We named Jeffrey Liaw as our co-chief executive officer in April 2022 and as our chief executive officer in April 2024.
No restructuring theatre
5 of 5
Restructuring programmes, company-wide rebrands and strategy overhauls in ten years of annual reports.
How all 12 companies answered thisAcross the ten annual reports read, the only related item is a risk note about a possible order from the CMA to sell part of the business. They show no announced restructuring, rebrand or strategy overhaul.
In the event of a divestiture order by the CMA, the assets disposed may be sold for substantially less than their carrying value.
02People before plans
73 of 100 3 of 3 answeredA real system for developing people
3 of 5
The people section of the annual report and the proxy statement.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe proxy statement says 'We invest in our employees ... conduct employee training'. It names no program and gives no numbers. A search of the annual report found no rounds of layoffs.
We identify and attract top talent that aligns with our values and objectives.
We invest in our employees, maintain robust safety guidelines, conduct employee training, and promote inclusion across our workforce.
Executives stay
5 of 5
Filings that report officer departures over the last three years.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe only named executive officer shown leaving in the filings on officer changes is Jeffrey Liaw as chief executive (filing of 2026-06-29). Johnson's 2024 change was a change of role, not a departure.
Mr. Adair succeeds Jeffrey Liaw, who will step down as Chief Executive Officer and principal executive officer and will resign from the Board, each effective as of the Transition Date.
Mr. Liaw stepped down as Chief Executive Officer and resigned from the Board, in each case effective as of July 31, 2026 (the “Transition Date”).
The best people on the biggest opportunities
3 of 5
Who runs the main growth area, and where they came from.
How all 12 companies answered thisJane Pocock moved from chief executive of UK operations to President in August 2026. No filing says the move was made to run the main growth area.
On July 8, 2026, Copart, Inc. (the “Company”) announced that it has appointed Jane Pocock, the Company’s current CEO of its United Kingdom operations, as the Company’s new President to fill the previously vacant position, effective as of August 1, 2026.
Jane Pocock, 55, has served as our President since August 2026 and joined Copart in January 2019 as Managing Director of Copart UK.
03Narrow focus
80 of 100 2 of 3 answeredBest in the world at something
Could not assess
Market position claims and the sources given for them.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe annual report only calls the company 'a leading global provider' with a 'leading market position'. It makes no claim to be number one and gives no market share figure.
Found in the filings, but not enough to settle a mark:
We are a leading global provider of online auctions and vehicle remarketing services with operations in the United States (“U.S.”), the United Kingdom (“U.K.”), Germany, Brazil, Canada, the United Arab Emirates (“U.A.E.”), Spain, Finland, Oman, the Republic of Ireland, and Bahrain.
The same business for a decade
5 of 5
The business description from ten years ago beside the latest one.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe business descriptions in the 2016 annual report and in the latest one both describe 'online auctions and vehicle remarketing services'. Only the list of countries differs.
We are a leading provider of online auctions and vehicle remarketing services in the United States (U.S.), Canada, the United Kingdom (U.K.), the United Arab Emirates (U.A.E.), Oman, Bahrain, Brazil, Ireland, Spain, and India. We also provide vehicle remarketing services in Germany.
We are a leading global provider of online auctions and vehicle remarketing services with operations in the United States (“U.S.”), the United Kingdom (“U.K.”), Germany, Brazil, Canada, the United Arab Emirates (“U.A.E.”), Spain, Finland, Oman, the Republic of Ireland, and Bahrain.
A clear way of making money per unit
3 of 5
Whether management reports profit or revenue per customer, store, shipment or similar.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe annual report mentions 'an increase in revenue per car' for one year only. It reports no five-year series and no profit measure per unit.
The increase in the U.S. was primarily driven by an increase in revenue per car, which was due to a change in mix of vehicles sold, which was offset by a decrease in volume.
04Discipline and straight talk
73 of 100 3 of 3 answeredCareful with capital
4 of 5
Arithmetic on ten years of figures reported to the SEC: the change in share count and debt against free cash flow.
How all 12 companies answered thisArithmetic from SEC figures gives 4. Not lowered: Purple Wave cost $108.0 million, far under a fifth of the company's value, and the ACV deal is not completed.
Ten years of figures the company reported to the SEC. Its annual reports at sec.gov
Faces bad news squarely
3 of 5
The worst quarter or year of the last five, and what management said next.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe results release for the quarter ended October 31, 2022 names Hurricane Ian and about $25 million of costs as the cause. No earnings call shows a fix, and the filings read do not confirm that this was the worst period.
For the three months ended October 31, 2022, revenue, gross profit, and net income were $893.4 million, $369.5 million, and $245.8 million, respectively. These represent an increase in revenue of $83.2 million, or 10.3%; a decrease in gross profit of $15.5 million, or 4.0%; and a decrease in net income of $14.5 million, or 5.6%, respectively, from the same period last year.
On September 28th, 2022, Hurricane Ian, a Category 4 hurricane, came ashore in Florida, with sustained winds of 150mph, the first such Category 4 storm to impact Southwest Florida since Hurricane Charley in 2004. Hurricane Ian adversely impacted the operating results for the three months ended October 31, 2022 resulting in additional costs of approximately $25 million.
Earnings backed by cash
4 of 5
Arithmetic: five years of free cash flow against reported profit, and whether results were ever restated.
How all 12 companies answered thisOver five years, free cash flow was 0.713 times net income, which gives a 4. The SEC filing list shows no restatement filing in the last 10 years.
Ten years of figures the company reported to the SEC. Its annual reports at sec.gov
05Steady compounding
80 of 100 3 of 3 answeredSteady growth, year after year
5 of 5
Arithmetic: years of falling revenue out of the last ten.
How all 12 companies answered thisRevenue did not fall in any of the last ten years, which gives a 5.
Ten years of figures the company reported to the SEC. Its annual reports at sec.gov
No pivots or short-lived programmes
5 of 5
Strategy statements across ten years of annual reports.
How all 12 companies answered thisThe 2016 annual report already describes the core business as online auctions. The filings read list no abandoned or short-lived program in ten years.
Our reliance on intellectual property rights has increased significantly in recent years as we have implemented our auction-style sales technologies across our business and ceased conducting live auctions.
We are a leading provider of online auctions and vehicle remarketing services in the United States (U.S.), Canada, the United Kingdom (U.K.), the United Arab Emirates (U.A.E.), Oman, Bahrain, Brazil, Ireland, Spain, and India. We also provide vehicle remarketing services in Germany.
A widening lead
2 of 5
Arithmetic: operating margin in the last three years against the three before.
How all 12 companies answered thisOperating margin moved by -2.1 points between the two three-year periods, which gives a 2. The annual report's unmeasured line about 'market share gains' is not enough data to change it.
Ten years of figures the company reported to the SEC. Its annual reports at sec.gov
Historically, the acquisition and development of new facilities has both enabled and resulted from market share gains in our core salvage vehicle remarketing business.