Question 4.1 · Discipline and straight talk · arithmetic

Careful with capital

Arithmetic on ten years of figures reported to the SEC: the change in share count and debt against free cash flow. Answered for 11 of 12 companies so far.

Marks run from 1 to 5. "Could not assess" means the filings did not show enough to choose a mark.

How each company answered

Grouped by mark. Not a ranking of the shares.

Marked 5 of 5 7 companies

ADBE

Adobe

5 of 5

Read the Adobe study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5. No cut: the Semrush purchase at about $1.9 billion is small against the size of the company, and the Figma deal was ended, not completed.

CTAS

Cintas

5 of 5

Read the Cintas study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5. Not lowered: the UniFirst deal at about $5.5 billion is far under a fifth of the company's value and had not closed.

EXEL

Exelixis

5 of 5

Read the Exelixis study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5: share count down 11.4% in five years and no debt against free cash flow. The only deal with a stated cost, the $80 million Insilico licence, is far below a fifth of the company's value.

FAST

Fastenal

5 of 5

Read the Fastenal study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5: share count down 0.09%, debt 0.12 times free cash flow. No acquisition cost appears in the filings read, so no adjustment.

JKHY

Jack Henry

5 of 5

Read the Jack Henry study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5: shares down 5.05% in five years, debt 0.03 times free cash flow. The Victor acquisition at about $42.4 million in cash is far below a fifth of the company's value.

NVDA

Nvidia

5 of 5

Read the Nvidia study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5. No cut: the Groq deal, about $13 billion in cash, is far below a fifth of the company's value, and the cost of the Hugging Face deal is not given.

ODFL

Old Dominion Freight Line

5 of 5

Read the Old Dominion Freight Line study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 5: shares down 10.7% in five years, debt 0.01 times free cash flow. No acquisition in the last five years is shown.

Marked 4 of 5 1 company

CPRT

Copart

4 of 5

Read the Copart study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 4. Not lowered: Purple Wave cost $108.0 million, far under a fifth of the company's value, and the ACV deal is not completed.

Marked 3 of 5 3 companies

BMY

Bristol Myers Squibb

3 of 5

Read the Bristol Myers Squibb study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 3: share count down 9.7% in five years, debt 3.49 times free cash flow. Not lowered: no quote shows an acquisition above a fifth of the company's value at the time, and Karuna at $14.0 billion was below that line on the figures quoted.

VEEV

Veeva Systems

3 of 5

Read the Veeva Systems study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 3. The only acquisition with a stated cost, Ostro at about $100 million, is far below a fifth of the company's value.

DIS

Walt Disney

3 of 5

Read the Walt Disney study

Arithmetic from SEC figures gives 3. Not adjusted: the $8.6 billion Hulu payment and the $1.3 billion FuboTV value are well under a fifth of the company's value, and no quote shows a larger deal.

Could not assess 1 company

LEN

Lennar

Could not assess

Read the Lennar study

The figures on file give no five-year change in share count, so the arithmetic could not be done. The only acquisition in five years, Rausch at about $240 million of net assets, is too small to matter either way.

One study
a month

A new company, every answer with its source. No tips, no alerts, no hurry.