Question 4.2 · Discipline and straight talk

Faces bad news squarely

The worst quarter or year of the last five, and what management said next. Answered for 4 of 12 companies so far.

Marks run from 1 to 5. "Could not assess" means the filings did not show enough to choose a mark.

How each company answered

Grouped by mark. Not a ranking of the shares.

Marked 4 of 5 1 company

NVDA

Nvidia

4 of 5

Read the Nvidia study

In the weakest quarter (the third quarter of fiscal 2023, revenue down 17%) the chief executive named the cause ('correcting inventory levels') and the way forward ('paving the way for new products'). Two quarters later revenue was up 19%, with supply 'significantly increasing'. No earnings call confirms what was said on the next call, so the mark stops short of a 5.

NVIDIA (NASDAQ: NVDA) today reported revenue for the third quarter ended October 30, 2022, of $5.93 billion, down 17% from a year ago and down 12% from the previous quarter.

Marked 3 of 5 3 companies

CPRT

Copart

3 of 5

Read the Copart study

The results release for the quarter ended October 31, 2022 names Hurricane Ian and about $25 million of costs as the cause. No earnings call shows a fix, and the filings read do not confirm that this was the worst period.

For the three months ended October 31, 2022, revenue, gross profit, and net income were $893.4 million, $369.5 million, and $245.8 million, respectively. These represent an increase in revenue of $83.2 million, or 10.3%; a decrease in gross profit of $15.5 million, or 4.0%; and a decrease in net income of $14.5 million, or 5.6%, respectively, from the same period last year.

LEN

Lennar

3 of 5

Read the Lennar study

The release of 12 Mar 2026 names the cause: 'continued weakness in the market and an increased use of sales incentives'. No earnings call shows a named fix. Later gains in cycle time and inventory are not tied to it.

The decrease in average sales price of homes delivered in the first quarter of 2026 compared to the same period last year was primarily due to continued weakness in the market and an increased use of sales incentives offered to homebuyers.

DIS

Walt Disney

3 of 5

Read the Walt Disney study

The results release for the second quarter of fiscal 2024 names goodwill write-downs as the cause of the loss. No quote names a fix.

Diluted earnings per share (EPS) was a loss of $0.01 for the current quarter compared to income of $0.69 in the prior-year quarter. Diluted EPS decreased to a nominal loss due to goodwill impairments in the quarter, partially offset by higher operating income at Entertainment and Experiences.

Could not assess 8 companies

ADBE

Adobe

Could not assess

Read the Adobe study

The filings read show no weak quarter and hold no earnings call. A change in how fiscal 2026 results are reported is shown, but it is not tied to a bad period.

Beginning in FY2026, we will implement reporting and guidance changes. Our reporting and guidance will focus on customer group subscription revenue and total company ending ARR year-over-year growth, while also guiding on total Adobe revenue and EPS. We will continue to report subscription revenue for Digital Media and Digital Experience as supplemental disclosures.

BMY

Bristol Myers Squibb

Could not assess

Read the Bristol Myers Squibb study

The net loss of $11.9 billion in the first quarter of 2024 is put down to the $12.1 billion Karuna charge, and Cobenfy was later approved. No earnings call shows management naming a fix.

On a GAAP and non-GAAP basis, Acquired IPRD increased to $12.9 billion from $75 million, primarily due to the Karuna asset acquisition and SystImmune collaboration.

CTAS

Cintas

Could not assess

Read the Cintas study

The weakest quarter was the third quarter of fiscal 2026 (margin 23.2% vs 23.4%). The releases name its cause: a gain of 15 million dollars on a land sale that does not repeat. No earnings call shows a fix.

Operating income as a percent of revenue was 23.2% in the third quarter of fiscal 2026 compared to 23.4% in last year's third quarter.

EXEL

Exelixis

Could not assess

Read the Exelixis study

The net loss of $(30.2) million in the fourth quarter of 2022 is identified, and the release names the research and development costs behind it. With no earnings calls, a fix stated on the next call cannot be checked.

GAAP net income (loss) for the quarter ended December 31, 2022 was $(30.2) million, or $(0.09) per share, basic and diluted, as compared to GAAP net income of $95.2 million, or $0.30 per share, basic and $0.29 per share diluted, for the comparable period in 2021.

FAST

Fastenal

Could not assess

Read the Fastenal study

No earnings call covers the worst year (2024, measured by net income). The letters say only that the company 'didn't wait for the market to lift us'.

We didn’t wait for the market to lift us.

JKHY

Jack Henry

Could not assess

Read the Jack Henry study

The only quote names the cause of one quarter's decline (a 64% fall in deconversion fees, quarter ended December 31, 2022). No earnings call shows a fix, and nothing ranks it as the worst period.

Services and support revenue decreased for the three months ended December 31, 2022, primarily driven by a decrease of 64% in deconversion fees, partially offset by growth in data processing and hosting fees of 12%.

ODFL

Old Dominion Freight Line

Could not assess

Read the Old Dominion Freight Line study

There are no earnings calls to show management naming a cause and a fix. Only the 2026 releases show the operating ratio improving to 70.1% and 71.5%.

Our operating ratio improved by 450 basis points to 70.1% for the second quarter of 2026.

VEEV

Veeva Systems

Could not assess

Read the Veeva Systems study

Operating income fell 9% in fiscal 2023 and the release names no cause. The filings read hold no earnings calls to show what management said next.

Fiscal year 2023 operating income was $459.1 million, compared to $505.5 million one year ago, a decrease of 9% year over year.

One study
a month

A new company, every answer with its source. No tips, no alerts, no hurry.