Fifteen questions, the same for every company
Five areas, three questions each. Every question is marked from one to five against a description fixed in advance, from the company's own filings. Four of them are plain arithmetic. When the filings do not show enough to judge a question, it is left open.
Quiet leadership
Leaders who credit others and own the misses.
- Question 1.1
The chief executive credits others and owns the misses
The last two letters to shareholders and what the chief executive says alongside results.
1 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
-
10 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 1.3
No restructuring theatre
Restructuring programmes, company-wide rebrands and strategy overhauls in ten years of annual reports.
12 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
People before plans
The right people first, then the strategy.
- Question 2.1
A real system for developing people
The people section of the annual report and the proxy statement.
12 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
-
10 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 2.3
The best people on the biggest opportunities
Who runs the main growth area, and where they came from.
8 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
Narrow focus
One thing done better than anyone, and a clear way it makes money.
-
6 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 3.2
The same business for a decade
The business description from ten years ago beside the latest one.
11 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 3.3
A clear way of making money per unit
Whether management reports profit or revenue per customer, store, shipment or similar.
9 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
Discipline and straight talk
Careful with capital, honest about bad news.
- Question 4.1 · arithmetic
Careful with capital
Arithmetic on ten years of figures reported to the SEC: the change in share count and debt against free cash flow.
11 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 4.2
Faces bad news squarely
The worst quarter or year of the last five, and what management said next.
4 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 4.3 · arithmetic
Earnings backed by cash
Arithmetic: five years of free cash flow against reported profit, and whether results were ever restated.
12 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
Steady compounding
Year after year in the same direction, no lurches.
- Question 5.1 · arithmetic
Steady growth, year after year
Arithmetic: years of falling revenue out of the last ten.
12 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 5.2
No pivots or short-lived programmes
Strategy statements across ten years of annual reports.
6 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered
- Question 5.3 · arithmetic
A widening lead
Arithmetic: operating margin in the last three years against the three before.
10 of 12 companies could be marked on this so far. See how each answered